HAPPY CANADA DAY!!!
FANTALYTICS – VOLUME 9
As a special treat we bring you…
“Adam Forsyth’s Super Spectacular Summer Right Fielder Extravaganza”
Nelson Cruz VS Hunter Pence VS Justin Upton VS Nick Markakis VS Andre Ethier
Move over Car & Driver! Take a hike Road & Track!
Here comes WaiverSharks biggest comparison test - EVER! Rather than run a picture of these right field phenoms, since we’re pretty certain you know what they look like, we decided it’d be fun to post the vehicle we think suits each player’s style.
We break down the Texas Rangers - Nelson Cruz, Houston Astros - Hunter Pence and the D-backs - Justin Upton today.
We’ll follow up with the spine tingling conclusion to peg the finest fantasy baseball right fielder with the Baltimore Orioles - Nick Markakis and the Los Angeles Dodgers Andre Ethier - as well as our “Fantalytics Final Call” in our Thursday, July 2nd post!
With so much young talent in this position, we figured that we’d take the opportunity to switch up our regular 1-on-1 format and get down to the brass tacks to inform our faithful readers of who is going to be the best option moving forward when it comes to this highly contested position.
With 12-team leagues entering their second go around in their schedules, winners from the first rotation of the schedule will be looking to sharpen their match-ups in attempts to go undefeated, while losers in first go’ round will seek redemption. Take notes on who will continue to roll, and who will be slowly dragged back down to earth as we embark our first ever 5-player FANTALYTICS!
The Case for Nelson Cruz
What should Nelson Cruz - cruise in? A 2010 G8 Sport Truck or modern day El Camino! Sure, the project was scraped by General Motors, but with the dough Nelson will be making the next few years, he could afford to build his own!
Power to burn in a notoriously favorable home park gives this chic pick from previous seasons a gold star as Nelson Cruz has exceeded any expectations after a couple of iffy opportunities of failure. At 28 (will turn 29 on July 1st) it appears that Cruz has allowed disgruntled owners to easily forget the challenges endured in yesteryear by going deep 18 times while clubbing home 45 big RBI’s through his first 250 AB’s. Throw in his 11 swipes and this kid is really showing his worth in his first full-time, full season gig.
Cruz has touched close to a .300 BA on several occasions this season; however, sitting at the mid .260 range is probably an indication of where he will comfortably settle. Striking out nearly 25% of the time will hurt this average, and should he find the plate discipline that currently eludes him, he’ll be a more reliable .275 to .285 hitter.
The injury to Josh Hamilton and struggles of Chris Davis don’t help Cruz out as far as line-up protection goes; however, he is currently being relied upon to be a main contributor to a confusing Rangers attack and has to be considered a staple in the middle of the order for the near future.
Take note though; in being the “senior” of this group and currently in his “prime years” of professional baseball, Cruz is probably displaying what we should expect for the next five years right now. We must consider this when comparing him with the four others within this group.
The Case for Hunter Pence

What should Hunter Pence drive? Well, Pence is from Texas , so a Cadillac, but he’s tall so a shiny pearl white Escalade suits him…and since he’s a pretty efficient player – let’s make it a Hybrid baby!
After a somewhat forgettable “two steps back” season of 2008, this Texan has solidified himself as a solid five-tool fantasy contributor returning to the promise displayed in his rookie season. Hitting comfortably over the .320 mark, while powering double digit HR’s and close to double digit steals, Pence is being used effectively in the line-up by not being placed in a pressure filled position and commonly following the likes of a Carlos Lee, Miguel Tejada or the Big Puma to provide him with some quality pitches each time he digs in.
Pence isn’t getting the tremendous RBI opportunities that someone in the 3-4-5 spots do; however, he maintains a near .300 BA (currently .298) with runners on base and an above average .333 BA with RISP with two outs. This shows that Pence is getting more comfortable when submersed in high-pressure situations.
If we had to come up with a knock about Pence, it would have to be with his struggles for consistency. While it hasn’t been as magnified this season; last season, Pence had months of .260, .346, .200, .294, .223 and .302 and while his extra base power remained steady, his ability to get on base, steal and score runs was directly affected. Pence has worked hard to rid himself of any stigma of being an inconsistent hitter which has pleased fantasy owners that bought into this blue chip stud years ago.
The Case for Justin Upton

Justin Upton – Would Updog pimp his ride? Probably – But for sure, it’s gotta be bulked up & powerful! And since Baby Upton plays for the Baby Snakes out in Arizona - what better powerful desert crawler is there than a Hummer? …& maybe even a couple of “ladies” to help push BJ’s younger brother out of a sand dune!
After a somewhat disappointing 2008, many fantasy owners weren’t sure of what to expect from the MLB’s younger Upton brother and with the oft-anemic D’Backs offense constantly being a concern, you wouldn’t think that having a 21-year old leading the charge would be possible. However, Justin Upton is certainly laying the foundation for what will hopefully be an impressive fantasy career.
Find a Justin Upton Bobblehead on eBay
Ranking 1, 2 or 3 in every statistical team category at his age is more than impressive and through 71 team games having an OPS above 1.000 is nothing short of phenomenal. He has cut down on his whiffs by nearly an entire AB (2.94AB/K in ’08 compared to 3.87AB/K this season) all the while appearing more patient each time he digs in. Positioned 3rd in the line-up, Upton has been given every opportunity to thrive and is showing that he isn’t willing to move from such an honor.
Upton is one homer away from tying last years’ mark of 15 (in over 100 less AB’s), is challenging to score 100 runs and could inevitably reach the 30/30 plateau. Not bad for being on a team that ranks 3rd from the bottom in terms of BA that typically depends on its’ pitching staff to win games.
Solid concern of the 2005 1st overall pick and his whiff-ability has a tendency to expose some other weaknesses (.267 BA with RISP), as striking out in big moments and his inefficiency in battling back when behind in a count are regularly spotlighted. You can discount a majority of that to his youth and lack of exposure; however, this will definitely be a key focus for his future development.
Tune in Thursday July 2nd to read the other two Right Field playas - and who we think is the #1 fantasy baseball right fielder for 2009!